Bought an Amana Fridge 10 years ago and it still works great. I would buy another one when I need a new one.
I think there are lots of good ones out there and sometimes you get a lemon.
This has happened to me in the past with other items that were deemed to be a problem free item. The split shelf is great in the sense it has no lip so you can put long items on it if need be. The door bins move around easily and have not cracked or deteriorated and the door seal is fine.
I have also never had any problem with the freezer.
Product or Service Mentioned: Amana Refrigerator.
Reason of review: Good quality.